Pet Custody in Divorce or Separation: What You Need to Know – Todd Zimmer Law & Associates
When a couple separates or gets divorced, many people don’t think about the emotional and legal implications of pet custody. While traditionally pets were viewed as property under the law, this perspective has shifted in recent years, especially as pets are increasingly seen as family members. This shift raises important questions: How often is pet custody an issue in divorce, and how do judges decide who gets custody of the family pet?
How Often is Pet Custody an Issue in Divorce or Separating Partners?
As the pet-owning culture continues to grow, the question of who gets to keep the pet has become a common concern in divorce or separation proceedings. According to recent studies and divorce attorneys, the number of pet custody cases has increased steadily, especially in Suffolk County, Long Island, where pets are seen not just as companions but as integral parts of families.
In fact, it is estimated that over 70% of households in Suffolk and Nassau Counties have a pet, and with divorce rates at a little over 60% on Long Island, the intersection of these two factors means that pet custody has become a significant legal issue in many divorce cases.
This emotional dilemma is particularly difficult when children are involved, but many separating partners face similar challenges when deciding who should retain ownership or the right to care for their beloved pets. In many cases, pets are considered “property” and their ownership determined by who legally purchased the animal or who has documentation proving their responsibility for the animal’s care.
How Do Judges Decide Who Gets Custody of the Pet?
In Suffolk and Nassau counties , as in many other places, the approach to pet custody has evolved. While pets used to be treated as mere property, recent changes in New York law and case rulings have allowed for a more nuanced approach to pet custody. Judges often take the following factors into consideration when determining which party gets custody of the pet:
- The Pet’s Well-being: New York courts are increasingly considering the well-being of the pet, treating them more like family members than property. This includes evaluating which party has been primarily responsible for the pet’s daily care, feeding, exercise, and medical needs.
- The Pet’s Relationship with Each Party: Judges may look at the bond between the pet and each individual. For example, if one partner has a stronger emotional connection with the pet and has been the primary caregiver, they may be awarded custody.
- Living Conditions: The living situation of each party is also crucial. A judge will consider the environment in which the pet will live after the separation. Factors such as the size of the home, whether the pet has access to a yard, or the ability of the owner to provide for the pet’s needs are considered.
- Pet Ownership and Care History: In some cases, if one party can prove they are the primary caregiver—through veterinary records, receipts for pet supplies, or other forms of documentation—this could play a role in the decision-making process.
- Mutual Agreements: In some cases, separating partners can agree on a shared custody arrangement or visitation schedule for the pet. These agreements can often be reached through mediation or collaborative divorce practices, and they help avoid prolonged litigation in court.
How Todd Zimmer Law & Associates Supports the Suffolk County Community
At Todd Zimmer Law & Associates, we understand the emotional and legal challenges of pet custody cases. As a locally based law firm in Suffolk County, Long Island, we take pride in helping families navigate the complexities of divorce, separation, and custody disputes—whether they involve children, pets, or both.
With an increasing number of Suffolk County residents owning pets, our team is committed to providing compassionate and effective legal counsel to ensure that both people and pets are protected during a difficult time. Whether through mediation, negotiation, or litigation, we advocate for our clients’ best interests, ensuring a fair and just outcome for all involved.
.